Client A called REALTOR^® B to list a small commercial property, explaining that he wanted to net at least $170,000 from its sale. He inquired about the brokerage commission and other selling costs. REALTOR^® B's response was: "You have indicated that $170,000 net to you from the sale will be satisfactory. Suppose we just leave it at that and take all of the selling costs and proceeds of the sale above $170,000." Client A agreed.

The property was sold to Buyer C for $220,000. After settlement, in which it was apparent that $50,000 would go to REALTOR^® B as commission, Client A and Buyer C both complained to the Board of REALTORS^® about REALTOR^® B's conduct in the matter, and a hearing was scheduled before the Board's Professional Standards Committee. REALTOR^® B's defense was that he had performed the service that Client A engaged him for precisely in conformance with their agreement. Buyer C had considered the property a good buy at $220,000 and was happy with the transaction until he learned the amount of the commission.

Based on your understanding of the Code of Ethics Article 1, what do you think the hearing panel concluded? Show Answer